| English or local name | Scientific name | Range | Last seen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jamaican giant galliwasp | Celestus occidus | Jamaica | 1851 |
| Guadeloupe ameiva | Pholidoscelis cineracea | Guadeloupe | 1928 |
| Martinique giant ameiva | Pholidoscelis major | Martinique | 1825 or 1928 |
| Gigarcanum (Kawekaweau) | Gigacarnum delcourti | New Caledonia | 19th century ? |
| Navassa curlytail lizard | Leiocephalus eremitus | Navassa | 1868 |
| Martinique curlytail lizard | Leiocephalus herminieri | Martinique | 1830s |
| Mauritian giant skink | Leiolopisma mauritiana | Mauritius | 1600 or 1650 |
| Cape Verde giant skink | Chioninia coctei | Cape Verde | 1912 |
| Rodrigues giant day gecko | Phelsuma gigas | Rodrigues, Frégate | 1841 |
| Tongan ground skink | Tachygia microlepis | Tonga | 19th century |
| Eastwood’s longtailed seps | Tetradactylus eastwoodae | South Africa | 1928 |
| Saint Croix racer | Borikenophis sanctaecrucis | Saint Croix | 19th century |
| Round Island burrowing boa | Bolyeria multocarinata | Round Island | 1975 |
| Carié’s blind-snake | Madatyphlops cariei | Mauritius | 1803 ? |
| Réunion giant tortoise | Cylindraspis indica | Réunion | 1840s |
| Ratas Island lizard | Podarcis lilfordi rodriquezi | Isla Ratas | 1950 |
| Santo Stefano lizard | Podarcis sicula sanctistephani | Santo Stefano | 1965 |
| Viesca mud turtle | Kinosternon hirtipes megacephalum | Mexico | around 1970 |
| Rábida Island tortoise | Chelonoidis nigra wallacei | Rábida | 1906 |
| Saddle-backed Rodrigues giant tortoise | Cylindraspis vosmaeri | Rodrigues | 1795 |
| Domed Mauritius giant tortoise | Cylindraspis inepta | Mauritius | 1735 or 1844 |
| Saddle-backed Mauritius giant tortoise | Cylindraspis triserrata | Mauritius | 1735 or 1844 |
| Domed Rodrigues giant tortoise | Cylindraspis peltastes | Rodrigues | 1802 |
| (Galápagos tortoise) | Chelonoidis nigra nigra | Floreana | 1846 |
| (Galápagos tortoise) | Geochelone nigra ssp. | Santa-Fé | 1890 |
| Narborough Island tortoise | Chelonoidis nigra phantastica | Fernandinha | Rediscoverd in 2019 |
| South Florida rainbow snake | Farancia erytrogramma seminola | Florida (South) | 1952 |
| Batillus blind snake | Anilios batillus | Australia | 19th century |
| Navassa Island dwarf boa | Tropidophis bucculentus | Navassa Island | 19th century |
| Island worm snake | Typhlops sulcatus | Hispaniola | 1800 |
| Saint Lucia skink | Alinea luciae | Saint Lucia | 1889 |
| Underwood’s Mussurana | Clelia errabunda | Saint Lucia | 19th century ? |
| Bibron’s whiptail | Contomastix charrua | Uruguay | 1977 |
| Redonda skink | Copeoglossum redondae | Antigua, Barbuda | 1873 ? |
| Navassa Island iguana | Cyclura cornuta onchiopsis | Navassa Island | 1950s ? |
| Christmas Island forest skink | Emoia nativitatis | Christmas Island (Australia) | 2014 |
| Barbados racer | Liophis perfuscus | Barbados | 1963 |
| Antiguan curly-tailed lizard | Leiocephalus cuneus | Anguilla, Antigua and Barbuda, Guadeloupe | 15th century |
| Günther’s dwarf burrowing skink | Scelotes guentheri | South Africa | 1887 |
| Reunion Island skink | Leiolopisma ceciliae | Réunion | 17th century |
| Rodrigues day gecko | Phelsuma edwardnewtoni | Rodrigues | 1917 |
| Réunion nactus | Nactus soniae | Réunion | after 1500 |
| Pinta Island tortoise | Chelonoidis abingdonii | Pinta (Galápagos) | 2012 |
| Hispaniola racer | Hypsirhynchus melanichnus | Hispaniola | 1910 |
| Jamaican racer | Hypsirhynchus ater | Jamaica | 1940s |
| Réunion skink | Gonglyomorphus bojerii borbonica | Réunion | 1880 ? |
| Smith’s hidden gecko | Cyrtodactylus celatus | Timor | 1924 ? |
| Lacépède’s ground snake | Erythrolamprus cursor | Martinique, Rocher du Diamant (Lesser Antilles) | 1962 |
Visited 12 times